top of page

Judge Lets Alex Murdaugh’s Defense Run New DNA Tests on Maggie Murdaugh’s Fingernails and Phone; Prosecutor Calls It ‘High Risk’

Oct 17
3 min read

A South Carolina judge on Friday allowed Alex Murdaugh’s defense team to run new DNA tests on evidence from his late wife Maggie Murdaugh’s fingernails and cellphone, a move the lead prosecutor called “high risk,” according to Fox News Digital and FITSNews.


Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin sided with the defense at an Oct. 16 hearing in Lexington, S.C., even though both sides agreed the testing will likely consume the last of the testable material, the outlets reported. McCaslin said due process requires that a defendant be given “a meaningful opportunity to present a full and complete defense,” according to Fox News Digital.


“This is a really important case,” McCaslin said, according to FITSNews. “They have every right to test it — and I’m going to let them test it.”


Murdaugh was convicted in 2023 of murdering Maggie and their son Paul at the family’s Moselle property in Colleton County. The South Carolina Supreme Court later overturned the convictions, finding that former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill improperly influenced the jury. His retrial is set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County, and he has maintained his innocence.

Quote card reading “This is a really important case. They have every right to test it — and I’m going to let them test it.” attributed to Judge Debra McCaslin, over a darkened photo of the Colleton County Courthouse.
Judge Debra McCaslin at the Oct. 16 hearing, as reported by FITSNews. Background: Colleton County Courthouse, Walterboro, S.C., where the 2023 trial was held; P. Hughes, CC BY 4.0.

WHAT THE MURDAUGH DNA TESTING WILL LOOK FOR


The defense plans to send the samples to Othram, a private lab, for Y-STR testing, a method that isolates DNA from the Y chromosome to build a profile of a male contributor in samples dominated by female DNA, Fox News Digital reported.


Defense attorney Phillip Barber argued that lab data shows unidentified male genetic material on the phone and under the fingernails of both hands, and the defense wants to know whether one man is the source of all three, according to both outlets. FITSNews noted the defense has not established that the same man contributed to all three samples. The process will take about 90 days, the defense said.


Barber acknowledged the DNA could have an innocent explanation, including contamination. “Maybe it’s different male DNA. Maybe it’s the same. Maybe it’s red herrings,” he said, according to Fox News Digital. “But as we keep progressing from one hand to two hands and now the phone, you know. It’s starting to look less and less like a red herring.”


“If you have an unknown person under both her fingernails and throwing the phone out the side of the road after she’s murdered, it’s not him,” Barber said, Fox News Digital reported.


THE PROSECUTION’S SIDE


Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters told the court the state was not trying to block independent testing. “We’re not trying to stand in the way of anything,” he said, according to FITSNews. His concern, he said, was that the test would use up limited reserve material, and whether both sides would see the results.


Waters said the defense’s own expert had described the material as close to a single-source sample. “This would be high risk and unlikely to generate anything,” Waters quoted the expert as saying, adding that initial measurements from Othram showed “goose eggs on the Y chromosome,” according to Fox News Digital. Waters also disputed that any profile suitable for comparison had been developed from the phone, FITSNews reported.


Because the testing could leave nothing for later, Murdaugh agreed in court to waive any further testing of the material in post-conviction proceedings, both outlets reported. The judge declined to make the defense hand over its results in advance, but said any scientific report it plans to use at trial must be disclosed under reciprocal discovery rules, according to FITSNews.


Former prosecutor Joshua Ritter, a Fox News contributor, told Fox News Digital the move could backfire: if the DNA traces back to someone with an alibi or an innocent explanation, the defense loses its “unknown male” argument.


McCaslin denied a separate defense request for broad ballistics evidence from other shootings, FITSNews reported. Murdaugh is due back in court Nov. 13.


Sources: Fox News Digital (Oct. 16, 2026); FITSNews (Oct. 16, 2026); WLTX (Oct. 16, 2026). Cover and in-post background: Colleton County Courthouse, Walterboro, S.C., by P. Hughes, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating*
bottom of page