Six Officers for More Than 800 Square Miles: GAO Finds 44% of BIA Police Posts on Tribal Lands Vacant
The Bureau of Indian Affairs had 93 officers for 167 approved positions, and after inflation it now spends 19% less on the policing it runs directly, federal auditors found. Interior generally agreed with GAO's two recommendations.
WASHINGTON — The Bureau of Indian Affairs had 44% of its law enforcement officer positions on tribal lands vacant as of May 2025, up from 37% in September 2022, according to a Government Accountability Office report released Thursday.
BIA had approved 167 officer positions across its nine districts and employed 93 officers, which left 74 vacancies, the report says. The bureau polices about 60 Tribes directly.
The report, "Bureau of Indian Affairs: Additional Actions Needed to Address Law Enforcement Staffing Challenges" (GAO-27-108433), was addressed to Senate Majority Leader John Thune and Sen. Mike Rounds, both South Dakota Republicans.
Six officers available
GAO visited the Crow Creek Sioux and Lower Brule Sioux reservations in South Dakota. The two BIA-run police agencies there often share resources. A BIA official estimated they need 35 officers to cover more than 800 square miles. BIA had allocated 17 officer positions to the two agencies and filled 12 as of July 2025. Six of those officers were available for patrol and other law enforcement duties. The other six were detailed to other reservations or on leave.
Representatives of five of the seven Tribes GAO interviewed said they were at or near minimum staffing for round-the-clock coverage, which leaves one officer to cover an entire reservation at any given time. In all three of GAO's listening sessions with tribal advocacy organizations, participants said an officer can take almost two hours to answer a call from the other end of a reservation.
One tribal representative told GAO about an arrest on a domestic violence complaint. Rather than transport the man several hours away and leave the reservation without an officer, the officer "drove him around for a few hours and then returned him to his home." The same representative said police in his community do not arrest juvenile offenders because there is no detention facility to hold them. A representative of another Tribe said the closest juvenile facility was five hours away.
Funding and pay
Adjusted for inflation, BIA's obligations for the policing it provides directly fell 19%, from $41 million in fiscal 2016 to $33 million in fiscal 2025. In nominal dollars they rose from $41 million to $45 million. Over the same period, inflation-adjusted funding for police that Tribes run themselves under self-determination contracts and self-governance compacts rose 2.9%, from $133.6 million to $137.5 million.
In 2023, BIA moved its police officers into a higher-paying law enforcement officer job series, which raised the starting grade from GS-5 to GS-7. The bureau got no extra money to pay for the change, and a BIA official told GAO the bureau can now employ 20% fewer officers than it could in 2023.
According to BIA data, three criminal investigators and "no tribal law enforcement officers" received retention incentives from fiscal 2022 through 2025. Recruitment incentives have filled 13 positions since fiscal 2023, but BIA offers them only at five agencies it classifies as hard to fill.
GAO cited BIA's 2021 report to Congress under the Tribal Law and Order Act, which estimated a funding shortfall of nearly $1.5 billion and a staffing gap of more than 11,600 personnel for law enforcement on tribal lands. The FBI reported about 4,100 open investigations on tribal lands at the start of fiscal 2026.
Background checks
The Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency conducts background investigations for BIA officer candidates. In fiscal 2025, the standard investigation for officers took an average of 138 days, according to DCSA data. BIA officials said the checks typically take several months to a year, and that candidates often take other jobs while they wait.
BIA already investigates officers hired by Tribes, in 30 to 45 days on average. BIA looked into seeking authority from the Office of Personnel Management to investigate its own federal hires in 2021 but did not pursue it, and Interior officials told GAO they could not estimate a timeline for pursuing one. The Senate passed the BADGES for Native Communities Act in December 2025. The bill would authorize a five-year BIA background-check demonstration program, but it had not become law as of October 2026.
Recommendations
GAO recommended that the Secretary of the Interior ensure BIA identifies and carries out additional actions to recruit and retain officers, possibly including incentives and housing. It also recommended that BIA work with Interior's Office of the Solicitor to pursue delegated authority to run its own background investigations for federal officer applicants.
Interior's Office of the Secretary told GAO by email that it generally concurred with both recommendations and had no technical comments. The Justice Department provided technical comments.
GAO said the information from its site visits and listening sessions is not generalizable to all Tribes.
Read the full GAO report, GAO-27-108433: https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-27-108433
Thumbnail photo: Rolf Blauert (Dk4hb), Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0





Comments