Judge Orders White House to Respond to ABA Demand for Law Firm Deal Records

A federal judge on Monday ordered the White House to respond to the American Bar Association's requests for the agreements the Trump administration made with nine major law firms in 2025, along with its communications with those firms and with several firms it allegedly targeted.
U.S. District Judge Amir Ali of the District of Columbia issued a 26-page memorandum opinion and order on Nov. 16, granting in part and denying in part the ABA's motion to compel the Executive Office of the President to answer 16 document requests. The ABA alleges that the administration "adopted an unlawful, coordinated policy of sanctioning law firms and their lawyers for engaging in speech the government does not like," as the opinion summarizes the complaint.
Ali granted narrowed versions of five requests and denied the other 11, some only for now. The parties agree that "a response" can mean producing documents or asserting privilege over them, the opinion says.
The agreements and the firms
The central request seeks "All Agreements, created on or after January 20, 2025, between the Administration and any Settling Firm." Ali wrote that it "concerns a very narrow and specifically defined set of documents that are central to the ABA's claims: the agreements the government made with the settling law firms."
"The government has not suggested that these agreements, which it acknowledges were made and shared with third parties, implicate executive privilege concerns or would be particularly burdensome to produce," he wrote.
The White House must also respond to requests for its communications from Jan. 20 to June 30, 2025, with nine firms the ABA alleges reached agreements with the government. The opinion lists them as Paul Weiss, Skadden, Willkie Farr, Milbank, Kirkland & Ellis, Allen Overy (now A&O Shearman), Simpson Thacher, Latham and Cadwalader.
A separate request covers communications from Jan. 20 to April 30, 2025, with five firms the government allegedly targeted that did not reach agreements: Covington & Burling, Jenner & Block, Perkins Coie, Susman Godfrey and WilmerHale. Both are limited to communications about a possible executive order against a law firm or an agreement with one.
"The communications sought in requests 1, 2, and 7 are directly relevant to whether the government made 'threat[s] of retaliatory sanctions' against law firms that would have 'deterred ABA members and their law firms from engaging in First Amendment protected activity,'" Ali wrote.
The government argued that under the Supreme Court's 2004 ruling in Cheney v. U.S. District Court, those records should come from the firms, which it subpoenaed in July 2026. Ali gave it until Dec. 28, 2026, to obtain documents from the firms and give them to the ABA. It must then respond as to any other responsive documents in its own files. The government recently told the court it had received only a small number of documents from the firms, the opinion says.
Drafts, memos and emails
Ali also ordered responses to narrowed requests for drafts of the law firm executive orders, including redlines and the messages that sent them, and for memoranda on the orders and on what press secretary Karoline Leavitt described as the president's "directive to hold Big Law accountable for their weaponization of justice and their lies."
He sharply limited the email searches. One covers emails naming a firm that received an executive order and using the word "EO" or a synonym, sent within 21 days before or after each order. The other covers emails about the directive sent from Feb. 13 to April 18, 2025. He excluded notes from meetings.
What was denied
Ali denied as moot the requests for communications with Boris Epshteyn and Steve Bannon, which the government conceded it must answer. He also denied as moot requests to identify the officials behind the orders, because the government had already responded by asserting presidential communications privilege over their names.
He put off requests for communications between the White House and agencies, which the ABA agreed to seek from the agencies first, and requests for social media posts and direct messages, which he called "overly broad." He also denied a request for notes on public statements, writing that "requiring the government to respond to this request would be particularly intrusive," noting that the government had identified "the President himself as a custodian."
The government had argued that the discovery would "disrupt the functioning of the Executive Branch" and "raise substantial separation-of-powers concerns." Ali wrote that the government "likely has the better reading" of Cheney in the legal dispute over its scope, but said his own discretion to manage discovery justified the limits he imposed.
Next steps
The parties must meet and confer by Dec. 4, 2026, on search terms and file a joint status report proposing a schedule for the government's responses. Ali denied as premature the government's request to pause discovery while it weighs an appeal; it may seek a stay if it does appeal.
Sources: Memorandum Opinion and Order, ECF No. 101, ABA v. EOP, No. 1:25-cv-01888 (D.D.C. Nov. 16, 2026) (https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.281674/gov.uscourts.dcd.281674.101.0.pdf) ; CourtListener docket (https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/70551899/american-bar-association-v-executive-office-of-the-president/) ; Bloomberg Law, Nov. 17, 2026 (https://news.bloomberglaw.com/white-collar-and-criminal-law/judge-approves-key-aba-records-request-in-suit-over-firm-attacks) ; Law&Crime via Yahoo News, Nov. 17, 2026 (https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/trump-doj-fails-bat-away-153542087.html).





Comments