Two Boston Judges Block Trump Limits on Foreign Students, Exchange Visitors and Journalists in Two Days

Federal judges in Boston ruled against two Trump administration restrictions on international students in two days. On Monday, U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV vacated a Department of Homeland Security rule that would have replaced “duration of status” with fixed periods of admission. The rule applied to F visa holders (students), J visa holders (exchange visitors) and I visa holders (representatives of foreign media). On Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Julia E. Kobick barred immigration authorities from enforcing two August directives that narrowed when international students can take internships for academic credit.
Fixed terms for students and journalists struck down
Under the decades-old current system, F, J and I visa holders are admitted for as long as they keep their status, with no fixed end date.
The DHS final rule, published July 17, 2026, would have ended that system. According to an analysis by the immigration law firm Fragomen, students and exchange visitors would have been admitted for no more than four years. Foreign journalists in I status would have been admitted for no more than 240 days, or 90 days if they held a passport issued by the People’s Republic of China (Hong Kong and Macau passports excepted).
The plaintiffs included the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the American Federation of Teachers, the UAW and The NewsGuild-CWA. Saylor’s opinion notes that one of the unions represents “journalists and other communications workers.”
Saylor, an appointee of President George W. Bush, had already postponed the rule on Sept. 14, the day before it was due to take effect. The administration has appealed that order to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit.
In Monday’s eight-page ruling, Saylor granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs. He found the rule “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law.” He wrote that DHS failed to weigh the rule’s costs and benefits and failed to consider less burdensome alternatives. He also wrote that its stated reasons, fraud and national security, “did not support the agency action.”
He also ruled on a second, independent ground: that DHS lacked the legal authority for the rule. He found the rule’s limits on Ph.D.-length study, joint degrees, changes of concentration and some new programs “not ‘reasonably related’” to the purpose of the F-1 program. “Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity—providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States—that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” he wrote.
He rejected the government’s request to send the rule back to DHS without striking it down.
The government’s case
DHS has argued that fixed admission periods and required extensions would give the government more chances to spot fraud, security risks and immigration violations. In court, it argued that the existing tracking database, the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), is a “data-reporting system for schools, not an immigration-status adjudication system.” Saylor rejected that argument.
After the ruling, a DHS spokesperson told Fox News Digital: “Where was the outrage when foreign nationals were abusing the system, violating the terms of their student visas, and making a mockery of our immigration laws?” The spokesperson said the administration is “cracking down on the rampant fraud to ensure only those truly intending to study in the United States are given the privilege.” Fox News reported that the White House plans to appeal.
Internship rules blocked
Tuesday’s ruling concerns curricular practical training, or CPT, which lets F-1 students take internships that are part of their curriculum.
The 24-page opinion says the government has treated elective training taken for academic credit as CPT since 1991. On Aug. 12 and Aug. 24, the Student and Exchange Visitor Program sent broadcast messages to schools saying CPT counts only if it is “required for all students pursuing that degree.” The messages warned school officials of possible loss of certification and of penalties. The Aug. 12 message cited “a rise in CPT authorizations” that did not meet the rules.
Kobick, an appointee of President Joe Biden, found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claim that the change was arbitrary and capricious. The plaintiffs include the Association of American Universities and the Presidents’ Alliance. The government had argued that the messages “merely implement the correct reading of the existing regulation.” “Correct or not, this new interpretation is inconsistent with the government’s previous position,” Kobick wrote. She added that the agency never acknowledged the change or weighed schools’ and students’ reliance on the old rule. Columbia University, in a sworn statement cited in the opinion, said it denied CPT to more than 120 international students for the fall.
Kobick stayed both messages nationwide while the case continues. She also barred the government from applying their interpretation to the plaintiffs and their members. DHS declined to comment to Reuters on Tuesday’s ruling.
Both decisions can be appealed to the First Circuit.
Sources: Memorandum and Order, Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration et al. v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-13799-FDS (D. Mass. Nov. 16, 2026), docket and opinion; Memorandum and Order, Association of American Universities et al. v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-14520-JEK (D. Mass. Nov. 17, 2026); Fragomen on the final rule, the vacatur and the CPT order; Fox News Digital (Nov. 17, 2026); Reuters via Investing.com (Nov. 17, 2026).





Comments