top of page

HHS Watchdog Rejects CMS Request to Drop Sepsis Payment Fixes, Citing $2.2 Billion Tied to 1991 Definition

40 minutes ago
3 min read

WASHINGTON — Medicare could have put an estimated $2.2 billion to better use in fiscal 2024 if it paid hospitals according to the updated medical definition of sepsis instead of one written in 1991, the Department of Health and Human Services' Office of Inspector General said in a report posted Thursday. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services asked the watchdog to remove both of its recommendations. OIG refused.

The data brief, "Medicare Could Put Billions of Dollars To Better Use by Adjusting Hospital Payments To Be Consistent with the Updated Definition of Sepsis" (OEI-02-24-00230), is dated Nov. 16. It is not a fraud finding: OIG did not review medical records and does not accuse any hospital of improper billing.

Two definitions

Under the 1991 definition Medicare uses for billing, "a fever and elevated heart rate with an infection can be considered sepsis," the report says. Experts' 2016 update, known as Sepsis-3, requires life-threatening organ dysfunction. A CDC sepsis program, CMS's own hospital quality program and some Medicare Advantage insurers already use the newer standard, according to OIG.

Medicare typically pays more when a stay carries a sepsis diagnosis than for other infections, such as pneumonia.

About 1 in 10 stays

In fiscal 2024, hospitals billed 615,007 stays, 9.4% of 6,556,071 inpatient stays, with sepsis but without severe sepsis or septic shock, the diagnoses that generally signal organ dysfunction. Medicare paid more than $12 billion for those stays, about $20,000 each, including patients' deductibles and coinsurance.

In 407,389 of them, the sepsis diagnosis directly raised the payment, by about $5,000 per stay on average. OIG's model estimates 355,004 of those stays would have been paid $4,405 less each, about $1.6 billion in all, and 52,385 would have been paid $11,493 less each, about $602 million.

Wide variation

Some hospitals billed more than one in five of their Medicare stays with sepsis, while others billed none. Stays of three days or fewer made up 30% of sepsis stays nationally, but 75% at some hospitals and 5% at others. Because Medicare pays the same rate within a payment group regardless of length, hospitals got about $16,600 per stay in the main sepsis group "whether the patient was in the hospital for 3 days or 2 weeks."

OIG said the patterns raise "concerns that some may be leveraging the broad definition to maximize their Medicare payments."

Not necessarily savings

The $2.2 billion is not a straightforward cut. Medicare's payment-group changes must be "budget neutral," the report says, so the money "would remain within the IPPS and could be put to better use via different hospitals and MS-DRGs." OIG said CMS could look for existing authority or seek it from Congress so the money becomes savings for taxpayers. CMS's response memo lists the draft under a different title: "Medicare Could Save Billions on Sepsis Stays."

The clash

OIG recommended that CMS adjust payments to reduce the incentive to bill sepsis stays and use its monitoring to follow up with hospitals. In a June 17 memo from Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz, CMS neither agreed nor disagreed with either recommendation and wrote, for each: "CMS continues to request that this recommendation be removed."

CMS said it "cannot propose to modify the MS-DRG GROUPER logic until the diagnosis code changes are made through the established consensus-based process," run by a committee CMS co-chairs with the CDC. It argued that OIG's method "does not account for patients diagnosed with sepsis under the current code set that are at risk of developing organ dysfunction," who "require an elevated level of monitoring and intervention." CMS said current data "supports the inclusion of sepsis on the major complications and comorbidities list." On monitoring, it said the recommendation "does not appear to require action outside of our existing oversight framework."

OIG answered that its recommendation "is not contingent on updates to the ICD-10 diagnosis codes," noting that CMS has removed and split payment groups before. On monitoring, it said "more must be done to ensure that hospitals are not using the broad definition to maximize payments."

According to CMS, a 2019 proposal to align the codes with Sepsis-3 stalled after public comment. CDC proposed new changes in March 2026.

Thumbnail photo: U.S. Navy photo by Petty Officer 1st Class James Stenberg (public domain)

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating*
bottom of page