top of page

USDA Delays 2024 Horse Soring Rule Again, Pushing It to the End of 2027

39 minutes ago
3 min read

WASHINGTON — The Agriculture Department has again postponed the parts of its 2024 Horse Protection Act rule that are still standing, moving the effective date from Dec. 31, 2026, to Dec. 31, 2027, according to a notice filed for public inspection Friday and scheduled to publish in the Federal Register on Monday.

It is the fourth time the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service has pushed back the rule, which was first set to take effect Feb. 1, 2025. The agency made the delay effective immediately and took no public comment, saying there was not enough time for a comment process before Dec. 31. The notice was signed Nov. 18 by Dudley Hoskins, USDA's under secretary for marketing and regulatory programs.

What the rule was meant to do

Soring is the practice of injuring a horse's legs and hooves, usually with chemicals or mechanical devices, to produce an exaggerated high-stepping gait in the show ring. APHIS says it is used mainly on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses.

The May 2024 final rule would have ended the industry's role in inspections, replacing inspectors licensed by horse industry organizations, known as Designated Qualified Persons, with inspectors trained and authorized by APHIS. It also banned action devices, non-therapeutic pads and certain substances on Tennessee Walking and racking horses, and replaced the decades-old "scar rule" with a new standard for spotting skin changes linked to soring, according to APHIS's 2024 announcement.

Industry wins in court

Much of that has since been struck down. On Jan. 31, 2025, U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk of the Northern District of Texas ruled in a suit brought by the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association that the ban on pads, action devices and substances exceeded USDA's authority, and that the new skin-condition standard and the rule's review procedures denied due process. He upheld the switch to USDA-authorized inspectors.

In a second case, Gould v. USDA, Kacsmaryk ruled on Aug. 28 that USDA's existing scar rule and its "no-showback" policy, which barred a horse found noncompliant from later classes at the same show, exceed the agency's authority, and that its disqualification process lacks due process. The Walking Horse Report, an industry publication, called the ruling a "landmark victory."

The notice also quotes a House Appropriations Committee report saying the 2024 rule "exceeds the agency's legal authority" and "severely underestimates the impact the rule will have on the 20,000 jobs supported by the Tennessee Walking Horse industry," and directing APHIS to withdraw it.

Why another delay

On Nov. 13, APHIS proposed withdrawing what remains of the 2024 rule and keeping industry-licensed inspectors under tighter rules. APHIS says the plan would add conflict-of-interest safeguards and training for those inspectors, require swabbing and blood testing, remove pads from first-place horses, ban masking agents, drop the scar rule and create on-site appeals. Comments close Dec. 14.

Friday's notice says that leaves too little time to review comments before Dec. 31. Letting the rule take effect while the agency considers withdrawing it "would almost certainly have disruptive consequences and result in 'regulatory whiplash' that could prove costly to the regulated industry," APHIS wrote.

Animal-welfare groups object

Humane World for Animals, formerly the Humane Society of the United States, and its affiliate Humane World Action Fund condemned the Nov. 13 proposal as a return to "the failed system of industry self-policing."

"Instead of walking away from this broken system for good, today's proposal from the USDA is like putting a fresh coat of paint on the same sinking ship," said Sara Amundson, president of Humane World Action Fund.

"The USDA needs to stop stalling, waffling and bowing down to the corrupting influence of those who sore horses," said Kitty Block, president and CEO of Humane World for Animals.

The groups are also suing USDA in federal court in Washington, D.C., arguing that the repeated postponements amount to an unlawful "constructive withdrawal" of the rule, according to the Walking Horse Report. The Celebration has joined that case to defend the delay.

Neither side had commented publicly on Friday's postponement as of publication.

Thumbnail photo: Todd Behre, USDA APHIS, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating*
bottom of page